Thursday, July 24, 2014

Saturday, July 19, 2014

Simulating outcomes

Here are some simulations inspired by original question and hypotheses submitted in the second part of the assignment.
I selected a 5 min count of arrivals at grass border obtained on June 23 (central trail, evening). Using the excel random function, I added to these real field data simulated crossing times t and simulated covered distance during crossing d (two variables to be measured on video recordings of the trail traffic in the study project). Covered distance increases by zigzagging and represents an excess of work.
Here are simulated possible outcomes if the following hypotheses are true:
1. Traffic in bursts doesn't save time or energy (light blue curves). 
2. Help from escorting leaders acts to save time and energy (red curves)
3. Enhanced marking by trail laying acts to save time and energy (dark blue curves).
Hypotheses 1 and 2 are mutually exclusive. So are hypotheses 1 and 3. Hypotheses 2 and 3 can coexist.



The principal inspiration came from an ant colony in my backyard. I however acknowledge the fantastic published works of the "ant team" of the Université libre de Bruxelles (ULB). In their abstracts and papers with free web access, I could find the confirmation that my project probably stands on sufficiently solid scientific background. It also helped me in the wording of the project. I didn't contact in person the people from the ULB, because I am not a biologist and am retreated from an other Faculty.






Monday, July 07, 2014

Territorial affairs

Until now I didn't report how the black and red ants occupy the backyard territory.
Here are nesting areas which could be ascertained:

Nesting areas of red ants (R01 to RO4) and black ants (B01 to B05)

Some pictures of the nesting areas (B05 was not clearly localized, but is inferred from the ant traffic in this region):

B01, near pond
B02, under stone


B03, in the grass

B04, the starting area of foraging trails E, C and W







R01, near pond

R03, in the grass area

R04, in the grass area
R02, nead pond





Sunday, July 06, 2014

Time to come out of the shadows

The past weeks, I was busy with the course itself, the video lectures, the weekly quizzes and the peer graded writing wich is due next monday. This late one is now submitted. Now I get some time now to transfer the handwritten notes into this blog. And it will be possible to make it public.

Of course, those who are looking at this blog for the first time will better start from the beginning...(see blog archive)

From what I knew previously, what I observed in my backyard, and what I could read, on a some superficial way I confess, some hypotheses are emerging about the behavior of the black ants on the trails crossing the garden cobble path.

Some features of the three trails seem interesting: their are natural ("in the wild"), permanent (still there today, even after some heavy rains), logically set (deserving three adjacent foraging areas), and subject to variable low to moderate traffic. The trails make different angles with the path and the intensity of the traffic varies accordingly. The path receives the sunlight from the east in the morning, remains in the shadow of the house at midday and is bathed again by the sun from the west in the evening. The food source appears rather constant, which can explain in great part the trails characteristics.

It seems that the arrivals frequently occur in small groups.
An example is given on this video (look first to its right): arrival of a group, followed by some returns.

Ipad mini on
 improvised stand



A burst of arrivals in successive packs can also be viewed on the video posted on my blog entry of June 12.

Also interesting is a graph of the individual arrivals and returns on each trail during the three 5 min counting periods on the last observation day.
Arrival bursts are the more obvious on the eastern trail. A departure burst is present in the first min on the central trail. Arrival and departure in pair are frequent on the western trail.

Eastern trail


Central trail

Western trail




Group recruitment in the nest is certainly at the basis of the traffic patterns. These phases of recruitment apparently occur in bursts. They are probably triggered by the arrival of the returning ants loaded with food.
It is possible that the journey to the foraging area is facilitated by leadership in the arriving teams, either shared by the members or exercised by one single pilot ant. Pairs may have been formed and aggregate in packs for a higher degree of grouping. It would also be interesting to verify if a" burst effect" allows an enhancement of the laying of the trail and can boost the traffic speed for the following ants. This burst effect could also be beneficial for the returning ants which in turn contribute to lay the trail. I didn't see real signs of leadership in the ants returning from foraging. They departure is probably driven by the completion of their foraging task or a decrease in food supply. Therefore returns occur more at random. The return speed is also depending on the carried load.

From this analysis, I feel now ready to prepare part 2 of the assignment: "Based on your observations, you will then be required to ask a scientific question about the behaviour of your chosen animal, and think about how you could go about answering this question scientifically..."
The requirements on academic integrity for my project submission imply that this must not be discussed here.

For these reflexions, I want to mention what I consider as my main sources of inspiration:

- The 2013 Symposium of the Delwart Foundation, Brussels, October 2013, which I was immensely lucky to attend. Particularly pertinent for the present topic was the session chaired by Martin Giurfa  with the presentation of Jean-Louis Deneubourg.

-The conference of Odile Petit (CNRS, Strasbourg): Prise de décision, leadership et origines anormales de la démocratie, Colloque Wallace 2013 of the Académie Royale de Belgique.

- The subchapter "recruitment" in  The Ants, Hölldobler & Wilson.

- My grand-daughter's dog, Kintaro, a Shiba Inu, who exhibits comprehensive signs of leadership when requesting his our daily stroll and when maintaining in group the family during geocaching.

Dog Kintaro near the observation field




.


Tuesday, June 24, 2014

Some basic descriptive statistics

The data are now entered in the excel sheet.
I am somewhat familiar with basic statistics, but never used the excel graphic system and statistical functions.
Please be thus indulgent.

Thus 8 days of observation (four pairs of day separated by a "rest" day)
Three daily observations of five min at each of the three spots.
This means 72 data lines in the excel sheet.

Observed number of crossings (n) and average traffic/min (tr) during the 8 days of counting:

Arrivals: n=562, tr=1,56/min
Returns: n=515,  tr=1,43/min
Total: n=1077,  tr=2,99/min

Variation of the average traffic on each trail during the observation period:


Influence of weather conditions and time of the day

Relationship between measured ground temperature and traffic:

Each point represents a five min count during the observation period



Evolution of average temperature and average traffic from day 1 to day 11 of the observation period:



Here is the influence of cloudiness on the traffic/min on the different paths: in ordinate, the average traffic /min





Here are the variations of the traffic on the trails with respect to the moment of the day:

Ordinate: crossing traffic/min
Inverse of mean traffic during the eight days observation period in function of trail length

Red square: center trail, blue diamond: eastern trail, green triangle: western trail













Monday, June 23, 2014

Foraging climax

Last day for the counts... Another perfect sunny day.

Morning:

Already some activity on the trails.
On W, a team of four hurries to the foraging area, with maybe some signs of organisation in their move. Better than to explain it, here is a sketch of what I believe I saw:



Also on W, two ants leave the grass border together. One of both bears a huge debris and takes much more time to cross: load is of importance.

Midday:

Regular traffic on E. Some traveling pairs in and out. Much "kisses"between arriving and leaving ants.
Numerous kisses too, during traffic bursts.
On W, less traffic. Some cross in little groups, others individually.

Evening

On E: arrival of a team of 8 to 10, with an ant of the group going backward, evocating a sheepdog, but I must be cautious when interpretating this behavior. The returns in contrast are mostly individual.

Counts show a record in traffic intensity today.

I made also some evaluation of the path crossing speed. For 3 arriving ants I could find respectively 6.56, 7.68 and 14.67 sec for a 57 cm trajectory. And for 2 departing ants, 12.06 and  16.75 sec for crossing the same distance. Thus big range (2 to 6 m/min).

Later at night, I could see on E an ant returning with a big leaf debris




Sunday, June 22, 2014

Summer solstice

Yesterday was the first official day of the summer. It was also a geocaching day for me. Today, after the shortest night of the year,  back to the backyard.

The weather forecast was correct and the ants are busier as expected.

Morning: 

Eastern tray: not much discipline today. Some arrivals in teams of 3 or 4
Central tray: arrivals in a pack, with the feeling that the last ones were accelerating to join the front runners.
Western (longer) trail: less traffic, slower speed  and more zigzagging trajectories in the two directions.



Also: in a group of four arriving ants, the two latest are slowing, and the two first "wait" for them before entering all together the foraging area.


Midday:

Less busy in general

Evening (20:00):

Busy again, on eastern and even more on central trail.
Arrivals mainly in teams, but individual returns.
Again a backward trajectory of a member of an arrival team after the late member slowed:


On western trail, modest traffic, but arrivals are also in packs when returns are mostly individuals.
Again a group of four where the late one is slowing and when one of the not slowing ants go backward, it seems "recuperated"


I see different  hypotheses for this phenomenon. C might be the pilot of D and go back when sensing that D doesn't follow. Or D is in reality a pilot. When C lost the contact of D by hurrying, C had no more directions and went backward. When meeting D, C again could be piloted.

Friday, June 20, 2014

Bible reading and Scholar consultation

Past two days

As expected, slight traffic on June 17. No counts on June 18. On June 19, the ants seems more active at the end of the day, when it is sunny again.
Yesterday, mostly cloudy.  The arriving ants are frequently in groups of 2 and at midday a typical group of four is seen on the way to the foraging area.

Morning

Today, slight traffic in the morning. On trail E, an isolated ant makes the way forth and back to eventually go back to nest area.



 On trail C, light traffic too. To note

- behavior suggesting recruitment of an hesitating departing ant by the following ant going straight ahead



 - A group of 4 on arrival is immediately followed by a group of 2 on departing.


Midday

on trail E, two ants exhibit erratic motions perpendicularly to the trail, and this during all the 5 min observation period:



On trail C: again an observation suggesting a recruitment for return of ant at the border by the next one





 Evening

On trail C: the ants seems to cross more quickly the path than previously in the day.
Between C and W: an ant is bearing a dead one and abandon it in a fissure of the path.

At night

After all these observations, I decide to depart from some of my naivety (which I maintained for avoiding observation bias, but can obscure to me some important observation details). I google scholar "ant leadership foraging".
Not a very new topic: see  Traniello 1977  and Hölldobler 1984.
I can also find a summary of this information in the "Bible", The_Ants Hölldobler & Wilson (I received this book as a gift, but until now had no much time to read it attentively).
Now, with "ant optimal forage", I got some newer information from the team of  my university. Ants are small, the world too! And following a MOOC from the antipodes may send you next door. On free access on the web: Collignon & Detrain 2010.




Monday, June 16, 2014

Typical Belgian climate

Today, the weather is fresh, cloudy, somewhat windy, in contrast with the 13 and 14 of June which were sunny days.
Observations periods:

09:15: very reduced traffic on the paths

15:21: traffic remains reduced
Two arriving ants. One slows. The other one, when at grass border, goes backward up to the slower one and after being behind it makes again the way to the border.


20:00 Reduced traffic again in cold weather (13°5 C near the ground) with little rain.
On E trail, one out of a pair two returning ants follows a somewhat erratic trajectory instead of the straight one. On C trail, the same phenomenon is seen. These pairs of ants are unusually slow.
.


On W trail: Only three arrivals of somewhat erratic ants in the 5 min period.

Weather seems a important factor for the traffic. Seeing the national weather forecast, I decide a planning of counting sessions of each time two days followed by one rest day, from June 13 to June 23. This is in accordance with my availability and will allow to see how the traffic varies with the weather conditions.

Weather forecast at the basis of the count planning


Sunday, June 15, 2014

Day of rest

Today, I couldn't make the counts , being away from house. However I had the opportunity in the evening to make some trials with the new ipad app that I bought for less than 2 €. It is named the multichrono interval stopwatch and designed for recording athletes training.

Multichrono report adapted to ants traffic


This is an example of 5:08 min observation at spot West. There were 7 incoming ants and 8 returning ants.
What is nice is that the time of arrival or departure is given. The multichrono by the way can also be used to measure the average speed of the ants on the visible part of a trail. Other events, like encounters, can be counted, but it's a little tricky to survey all the arrivals and departures plus the encounters when the traffic increases.

Saturday, June 14, 2014

An ants who's who, please

Today I inquired about the species of ants in the garden, and how to approach them. 
As a guide, I read the following pdf
.
I tried also to get the 2012 Belgian Ant Atlas, but the edition seems temporarily exhausted.
I must confess that I cannot identify the red smaller ants of my garden (4 to 5 mm should I say). The black ants (approx. 7 -8 mm) are probably Lasius niger, wich are common in Belgium (look here for a video from another source). 
There are also present in great number in my garden: let lift up a stone:



You can see "alates" (winged ants) which, following what I read,  are either virgin queens or males. These are on the way to mate on the flight. The video stops when my wife, attacked by an squadron of guarders, put the stone again in place.





Lasius niger care for lycaenid butterfly caterpillars and protect them from parasites. They enjoy in return the catepillars exsudates. Here is one of the numerous butterflies seen in y garden:



When counting, I observed a lot of ant head to head meetings of a second or so. For instance one arriving ant had three such meetings with returning ants. Meetings between arriving and departing ants were also observed at the border of the foraging area.
Here are some sketches of others observed behaviors:



Upper left sketch: again signs of triggering: an ant makes circles near C and its departure is triggered by an arrival. Upper right: an errant ant joins the main trail when the traffic reappears and goes then in the nest direction. Lower sketch: an errant ant cross the trail (with traffic ongoing) without changing its behavior.
Twice, a small red ant was seen near the border of the foraging area, making circles, but didn't join the black ones.

Friday, June 13, 2014

Counting the ants crossing the path

After a first counting trial yesterday, I could obtain results for today.
I could find a multiple counter as a free app in the apple store and after some changes, I ended up with the following scheme:


This means: as viewed from an observation spot (E in this example), output (return to nest) of 13 single ants plus 2 times a pair, thus a total of 15 ants out during the five minutes of observation. Also 5 single + 4 pairs = 13 inputs(arrival from nest) in the same period. Data will be transfered in an excel sheet, with date and time of observation, weather conditions, ground temperature and spot (E, C or W). The spot sequence will be changed each day. Three runs of observation per day (morning, midday, evening) consisting of a 5 min observation at each spot.
Note that the trigger counter is used when an arrival directly follows a departure, as I have the feeling that the arrivals at the border triggers the departures (this has of course to be ascertained).
Here is an actual field sketch from my note book describing a possible trigger phenomenon:
1. Ant A is making circles near border. 2. Ant B arrives with no reaction. 3. Ant C follows quickly. 4. Its arrival seemingly immediately triggers the departure of ant A.

Thursday, June 12, 2014

Ant foraging observation aera

I was impatient to start today (in fact: first attempt yesterday) the counting of the ants motions in the observation area.

Let me first describe this area: it consists of a paved path section behind the house, between a little area with plantations and the grass. Ants have apparently their nest in the planted area near the house. Three forage areas are located near the nothern path border. Let call them E for eastern, C for central and W for western. Between the nest area and the forage areas, three virtual trails (red lines) are used : 

The three trails crossing the path
E: east C: center W: west

Here is a video of ants traffic on trail C:














Wednesday, June 11, 2014

Why ants?

I had to make observations and provide field notes about a wild animal of my choice. I  loved the idea to choose this animal among the hosts of my garden. However I took a look before at the proposed webcams. After an horrific passage in the cockroach room from the Audubon Garden here, I was interested by the leaf-cutting ants webcam here. In fact, some thirty years ago, I spotted this phenomenon in the pure nature when on vacation in the South of France. I remember that I used a great part of my precious videotape to immortalize this queue of ants, despite the protests of my family who would prefer to be themselves on the tape.
So, when looking at the animals in my garden,- many birds including a corvid family, frogs and toads, an hedgehog, butterflies, snugs and snails, several spiders species, butterflies, bumblebees foraging clove flowers...- I had also a look at the ants. Some were black, the others red, some had their home near the pond, others under stones. And I could also spot near the house (hopefully not in the house) some foraging activity of the black ants. Even if they didn't carry relatively enormous debris of leaves, this convinced me to make them the actors of this blog.

My backyard, with the pond in the background.
In the foreground to the left, a path crossed by ant trails

And here follow my fields notes...My intention is to present these notes on a naïve and native way, a readable edition of my field note book:

Original notebook