Thursday, July 24, 2014

Saturday, July 19, 2014

Simulating outcomes

Here are some simulations inspired by original question and hypotheses submitted in the second part of the assignment.
I selected a 5 min count of arrivals at grass border obtained on June 23 (central trail, evening). Using the excel random function, I added to these real field data simulated crossing times t and simulated covered distance during crossing d (two variables to be measured on video recordings of the trail traffic in the study project). Covered distance increases by zigzagging and represents an excess of work.
Here are simulated possible outcomes if the following hypotheses are true:
1. Traffic in bursts doesn't save time or energy (light blue curves). 
2. Help from escorting leaders acts to save time and energy (red curves)
3. Enhanced marking by trail laying acts to save time and energy (dark blue curves).
Hypotheses 1 and 2 are mutually exclusive. So are hypotheses 1 and 3. Hypotheses 2 and 3 can coexist.



The principal inspiration came from an ant colony in my backyard. I however acknowledge the fantastic published works of the "ant team" of the Université libre de Bruxelles (ULB). In their abstracts and papers with free web access, I could find the confirmation that my project probably stands on sufficiently solid scientific background. It also helped me in the wording of the project. I didn't contact in person the people from the ULB, because I am not a biologist and am retreated from an other Faculty.






Monday, July 07, 2014

Territorial affairs

Until now I didn't report how the black and red ants occupy the backyard territory.
Here are nesting areas which could be ascertained:

Nesting areas of red ants (R01 to RO4) and black ants (B01 to B05)

Some pictures of the nesting areas (B05 was not clearly localized, but is inferred from the ant traffic in this region):

B01, near pond
B02, under stone


B03, in the grass

B04, the starting area of foraging trails E, C and W







R01, near pond

R03, in the grass area

R04, in the grass area
R02, nead pond





Sunday, July 06, 2014

Time to come out of the shadows

The past weeks, I was busy with the course itself, the video lectures, the weekly quizzes and the peer graded writing wich is due next monday. This late one is now submitted. Now I get some time now to transfer the handwritten notes into this blog. And it will be possible to make it public.

Of course, those who are looking at this blog for the first time will better start from the beginning...(see blog archive)

From what I knew previously, what I observed in my backyard, and what I could read, on a some superficial way I confess, some hypotheses are emerging about the behavior of the black ants on the trails crossing the garden cobble path.

Some features of the three trails seem interesting: their are natural ("in the wild"), permanent (still there today, even after some heavy rains), logically set (deserving three adjacent foraging areas), and subject to variable low to moderate traffic. The trails make different angles with the path and the intensity of the traffic varies accordingly. The path receives the sunlight from the east in the morning, remains in the shadow of the house at midday and is bathed again by the sun from the west in the evening. The food source appears rather constant, which can explain in great part the trails characteristics.

It seems that the arrivals frequently occur in small groups.
An example is given on this video (look first to its right): arrival of a group, followed by some returns.

Ipad mini on
 improvised stand



A burst of arrivals in successive packs can also be viewed on the video posted on my blog entry of June 12.

Also interesting is a graph of the individual arrivals and returns on each trail during the three 5 min counting periods on the last observation day.
Arrival bursts are the more obvious on the eastern trail. A departure burst is present in the first min on the central trail. Arrival and departure in pair are frequent on the western trail.

Eastern trail


Central trail

Western trail




Group recruitment in the nest is certainly at the basis of the traffic patterns. These phases of recruitment apparently occur in bursts. They are probably triggered by the arrival of the returning ants loaded with food.
It is possible that the journey to the foraging area is facilitated by leadership in the arriving teams, either shared by the members or exercised by one single pilot ant. Pairs may have been formed and aggregate in packs for a higher degree of grouping. It would also be interesting to verify if a" burst effect" allows an enhancement of the laying of the trail and can boost the traffic speed for the following ants. This burst effect could also be beneficial for the returning ants which in turn contribute to lay the trail. I didn't see real signs of leadership in the ants returning from foraging. They departure is probably driven by the completion of their foraging task or a decrease in food supply. Therefore returns occur more at random. The return speed is also depending on the carried load.

From this analysis, I feel now ready to prepare part 2 of the assignment: "Based on your observations, you will then be required to ask a scientific question about the behaviour of your chosen animal, and think about how you could go about answering this question scientifically..."
The requirements on academic integrity for my project submission imply that this must not be discussed here.

For these reflexions, I want to mention what I consider as my main sources of inspiration:

- The 2013 Symposium of the Delwart Foundation, Brussels, October 2013, which I was immensely lucky to attend. Particularly pertinent for the present topic was the session chaired by Martin Giurfa  with the presentation of Jean-Louis Deneubourg.

-The conference of Odile Petit (CNRS, Strasbourg): Prise de décision, leadership et origines anormales de la démocratie, Colloque Wallace 2013 of the Académie Royale de Belgique.

- The subchapter "recruitment" in  The Ants, Hölldobler & Wilson.

- My grand-daughter's dog, Kintaro, a Shiba Inu, who exhibits comprehensive signs of leadership when requesting his our daily stroll and when maintaining in group the family during geocaching.

Dog Kintaro near the observation field




.